Sponsored By

Empty container availability fears slide as demand wanes

Concerns over the availability of equipment in Asia and the limitations on the backhaul trades on the three major east -west routes have not materialised as expected with rates softening on both the headhaul and return legs.

Nick Savvides, Europe correspondent

March 6, 2024

4 Min Read
Evergreen containers on a vessel
Photo: Marcus Hand

Growth in empty repositioning since 2019 had seen an increase of 20% in terms of teu moved in 2023 compared to four years ago, but also the growth in full containers has increased globally by 2.5%, with an 8% increase in teu miles, according to one analyst using Container Trade Statistics.

“The need to move empty containers has grown significantly more than the need to move full containers, with the back-haul trades growing 2½ times faster,” wrote the analyst.

Speaking to Seatrade Maritime News anonymously one European freight forwarder debunked this view. “We move containers out of Asia and China to Europe and the US and we have had no problems getting empties,” he said.

The forwarder said he did not use the European lines, but instead booked with Cosco, HMM, Yang Ming and Evergreen mainly, and had no difficulties returning empties to ports either, compared to two years ago when empties had been stored off-site from ports as the empty boxes stacked up in destination terminals.

Darron Wadey at analysts Dynamar said that the number of empty boxes was close to the 2021 record, “when everything went supernova”, with CTS figures showing a 7% increase to 36.5 million teu.

“Yet, despite the similarities in size of the global imbalance, we are not experiencing the anything like the same mass hysteria of 2021 with everybody trying to secure apparently scarce container equipment,” explained Wadey.

Related:CMA CGM tops January schedule reliability

This year’s imbalance the extreme nature of the 2021 experience has softened considerably as the key US imbalance, in all trades, has reduced considerably more than Europe’s imbalance has expanded.

What is more the “total imports to these two regions – the headhaul routes – are also smaller than in 2021,” said Wadey.

“In fact global cargo volumes have shrunk or maintained station since 2021. Yet, over the same period, the container equipment fleet has kept growing,” he added.

Dynamar analysis shows the growth of the container fleet has outstripped container trade volumes by an average of 2.5% a year, for the last nine years.

“There should be sufficient flexibility within the system, to service the global demand for equipment and avoid a repetition of 2021’s scramble for container boxes, and any extra costs related to any perceived shortage,” concluded Wadey.

Xenata’s chief analyst Peter Sand said that the backhaul routes need to be understood on a regional basis, and while on the Pacific the backhaul trade remains the “baby brother” in a one-sided trade, the Red Sea crisis had seen the Europe to Asia rates double to perhaps $1,000 per feu.

Related:Red Sea crisis distorts container shipping market

Emily Stausbøll, Xeneta market analyst, said: "Major trades from the Far East into Europe and the US have been the main focus during the Red Sea crisis but the backhaul trades have also been impacted. 

"Similarly to the fronthaul trades, spot rates on the backhauls have been softening slightly in recent weeks as everyone adjusts to the new service schedules and it seems more apparent there is enough capacity to manage this demand."

Xenata’s own backhaul rate analysis shows that all three major east/west trades have seen a slight softening of rates on their backhaul legs. Out of the US rates had slipped to $892 from $933 high in January.

Atlantic backhaul rates out of the US were dipped to $563 per feu, and even the Europe to Asia trade, which has seen the biggest impact from the Red Sea crisis, had declined from a January high of $1,017 to $926 per feu.

“If there are rising costs for repositioning, these might be related to specific trades. Asia-Europe would certainly be one considering that its imbalance is indeed growing and because the (reverse) logistics supply chain has lengthened following the Red Sea diversions. Again though, such extra costs would not be because of insufficient numbers of boxes, and would be route specific,” said Wadey.

Drewry’s Simon Heaney also reported similar results, with the major trades all flat at the moment, with the Red Sea diversion meaning that the returns were taking longer to make it back to Asia.

Hong Kong analyst Linerlytica today reported that the “freight rate correction gathered pace,” as “carriers failed to defend their pre-Chinese New Year gains.” The analyst said the Shanghai Container Freight Index had subsided by 6.2% over the past week.

Weak demand meant carriers had not been able to mount a “serious GRI attempt for 1 March, ahead of the annual contract negotiations”.

About the Author

Nick Savvides

Europe correspondent

Experienced journalist working online, in monthly magazines and daily news coverage. Nick Savvides began his journalistic career working as a freelance from his flat in central London, and has since worked in Athens, while also writing for some major publications including The Observer, The European, Daily Express and Thomson Reuters. 

Most recently Nick joined The Loadstar as the publication’s news editor to develop the profile of the publication, increase its readership and to build a team that will market, sell and report on supply chain issues and container shipping news. 

This was a similar brief to his time at ci-online, the online publication for Containerisation International and Container News. During his time at ci-online Nich developed a team of freelancers and full-time employees increasing its readership substantially. He then moved to International Freighting Weekly, a sister publication, IFW also focused on container shipping, rail and trucking and ports. Both publications were published by Informa. 

Following his spell at Informa Nick joined Reed’s chemical reporting team, ICIS, as the chemical tanker reporter. While at ICIS he also reported on the chemical industry and spent some time on the oil & gas desk. 

Nick has also worked for a time at Lloyd’s Register, which has an energy division, and his role was writing their technical magazine, before again becoming a journalist at The Naval Architect for the Royal Institution of Naval Architects. After eight successful years at RINA, he joined Fairplay, which published a fortnightly magazine and daily news on the website.

Nick's time at Fairplay saw him win the Seahorse Club Journalist of the Year and Feature Writer of the Year 2018 awards.

After Fairplay closed, Nick joined an online US start-up called FreightWaves. 

Get the latest maritime news, analysis and more delivered to your inbox
Join 12,000+ members of the maritime community

You May Also Like