Sponsored By

Stretched and insecure supply chains hurt the poorest nations most

Extended supply chains are increasing shipping costs and are having a “profound impact” on global energy and food supplies as well as the global economy according to the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)’s latest maritime review.

Nick Savvides, Europe correspondent

October 28, 2024

3 Min Read
Container ship leaving port
Credit: AdobeStock

The Review of Maritime Transport 2024 released last week said that the small island and least developed states are bearing the brunt of these disruptions as they are the most vulnerable economies to the effects of climate change and political and social upheaval.

UNCTAD’s analysis: “Underscores the need for new infrastructure that is sustainable and resilient, a faster transition to low-carbon shipping and a crackdown on fraudulent ship registrations to safeguard global trade.”

The closure of the Suez Canal, which forced carriers to divert around the African Cape, absorbed vast amounts of tonnage as carriers attempted to maintain weekly schedules.

Suez is seen as a ‘chokepoint’ in supply chains, in a prolonged war that is showing few signs of ending, though fighting must eventually cease, with many observers looking to the end of 2025 or early 26 for a resumption of Suez trading.

Another chokepoint according to UNCTAD was Panama, which saw disruption caused by drought, forcing draught restrictions on vessels transiting the waterway, with some cargo initially heading to the US East Coast via Suez and then, following the Red Sea crisis heading to the US West Coast, travelling overland to eastern destinations.

“Regional examples show the wider impact.,” said UNCTAD, “East African nations like Djibouti and Sudan, reliant on the Suez Canal for a third of their trade, face severe disruptions. The Panama Canal disruption has increased sailing distances by 31% for affected routes.”

Related:Risk and returns – the positive impact of disruption for shipping

Longer routes saw costs for fuel, wages, insurance and chartering rise substantially and added to vessel emissions.

“For a 20,000-24,000 teu vessel on the Far East-Europe route, CO2 emissions alone add $400,000 in costs under the European Union's Emissions Trading System,” said the report.

Meanwhile small island and developing states have seen maritime connections fall 9% over the last decade.

In particular intra-regional trade fell 3% last year, and with regional trades accounting for more than one third of global trade, while the larger intercontinental trades increased 2%, this meant global container trades stagnated overall, according to Dyna Liners Trades Review 2024, which, like UNCTAD’s report was published last week.

Intra-Asia freight alone accounts for more than a quarter of global trade volumes which totalled 173.22 million teu in 2023, according to Container Trades Statistics, quoted in the Dyner Liners review.

With the least developed countries suffering the most UNCTAD called for:

  • Strengthened international cooperation to stabilise trade routes, enhance resilience and minimise supply chain disruptions from geopolitical and climate-related risks.

  • Improved monitoring systems for early detection of chokepoint disruptions and faster rerouting, as well as investment in early warning systems for ports.

  • Support for regional trade to reduce reliance on vulnerable routes and boost intraregional supply chains.

  • Enhanced global coordination to prevent protectionism and ensure open trade routes.

  • Active support of all UN Member States and stakeholders for IMO efforts to combat fraudulent ship registration through better verification, information sharing and strengthening of the legal framework.

Related:Managing global supply chains in times of disruption

New regulations will increase costs, as it is accepted that alternative fuels, whether it is ammonia, hydrogen or methanol will be more expensive than current fossil fuel prices. And although rates have fallen substantially, particularly on the major east/west trades, they remain elevated compared to pre-pandemic levels.

Average Drewry World Container Index (WCI) rates for this year are $4,058 per feu, which is $1,225 per feu higher than the 10-year average, which includes the unprecedented rates seen during Covid.

“The impact is especially severe for vulnerable economies reliant on maritime transport, as rising costs erode trade competitiveness, threaten economic stability and drive inflation,” said UNCTAD.

Quoting the Shanghai freight indexes for average rates for January to July this year, UNCTAD said Latin American rates of $9,026 per teu have more than doubled; South African rates have tripled to $5,426 per teu; and West Africa has seen a 137% leap to $5,563 per teu.

UNCTAD, however, believes that fleet renewal is moving too slowly, having outpaced demand the global fleet increased by 3.4% in 2023, mainly due to box ship and LNG carrier orders.

That is “below historical averages” said UNCTAD, and only 14% of the new tonnage was alternative fuel ready.

“Failure to accelerate decarbonisation could lead to higher costs, regulatory penalties and a loss of competitiveness as markets increasingly prioritise sustainability,” concluded UNCTAD.

About the Author

Nick Savvides

Europe correspondent

Experienced journalist working online, in monthly magazines and daily news coverage. Nick Savvides began his journalistic career working as a freelance from his flat in central London, and has since worked in Athens, while also writing for some major publications including The Observer, The European, Daily Express and Thomson Reuters. 

Most recently Nick joined The Loadstar as the publication’s news editor to develop the profile of the publication, increase its readership and to build a team that will market, sell and report on supply chain issues and container shipping news. 

This was a similar brief to his time at ci-online, the online publication for Containerisation International and Container News. During his time at ci-online Nich developed a team of freelancers and full-time employees increasing its readership substantially. He then moved to International Freighting Weekly, a sister publication, IFW also focused on container shipping, rail and trucking and ports. Both publications were published by Informa. 

Following his spell at Informa Nick joined Reed’s chemical reporting team, ICIS, as the chemical tanker reporter. While at ICIS he also reported on the chemical industry and spent some time on the oil & gas desk. 

Nick has also worked for a time at Lloyd’s Register, which has an energy division, and his role was writing their technical magazine, before again becoming a journalist at The Naval Architect for the Royal Institution of Naval Architects. After eight successful years at RINA, he joined Fairplay, which published a fortnightly magazine and daily news on the website.

Nick's time at Fairplay saw him win the Seahorse Club Journalist of the Year and Feature Writer of the Year 2018 awards.

After Fairplay closed, Nick joined an online US start-up called FreightWaves. 

Get the latest maritime news, analysis and more delivered to your inbox
Join 12,000+ members of the maritime community

You May Also Like